F & D Consulting finance × systems
Contact us
Case studies & guides

Guide Systems 4 min read

Zapier vs Power Automate vs Make (and n8n): which automation tool for a small business?

Four tools that all connect your apps and move data between them. How they differ, how they charge, and how to choose without locking yourself into the wrong one.

Oneth Dias

A woman drawing a process flowchart on a whiteboard

When a growing business starts automating, the question usually comes up within a week: “Should we use Zapier, Power Automate or Make?” All of them do the same basic thing. When something happens in one app (a form is submitted, an email arrives, an invoice is paid), they do something in another (create a contact, save a file, post a message). The differences are in what they connect to, how they charge, and who can look after them.

The four at a glance

ZapierPower AutomateMaken8n
What it isThe best-known connector of cloud appsMicrosoft’s automation tool, part of Microsoft 365A visual builder for multi-step automationsA workflow tool you can host yourself
Connects toThousands of apps (over 7,000)Microsoft 365 apps first, plus many othersA large catalogue of appsHundreds of integrations, plus any API
How you buildStep-by-step, easiest to startStep-by-step flows, familiar to Microsoft 365 usersA visual map of the whole scenarioA visual canvas, more technical
How it chargesMonthly plans by the number of tasks runStandard connectors come with Microsoft 365 business licences; premium connectors need a paid Power Automate licenceMonthly plans by credits usedFree to self-host under its own licence; a paid cloud service
Best forQuick wins across many cloud appsBusinesses that live in Outlook, Teams, SharePoint and ExcelComplex flows at lower running costTechnical teams who want control of hosting and data

Pricing for all four changes regularly, so check each vendor’s current plans before you commit.

How to choose

  • You already run on Microsoft 365. Start with Power Automate. Flows using standard connectors such as Outlook, SharePoint, OneDrive, Teams, Excel and Forms are covered by Microsoft 365 business licences. Check whether the apps you need are standard or premium connectors before you build.
  • You need to connect many different cloud apps quickly. Zapier has the widest catalogue and is the easiest for a non-technical person to set up. Watch the task count: high-volume flows can get expensive.
  • Your flows have lots of steps, branches or data handling. Make’s visual builder handles complex logic well, and its credit-based pricing is often cheaper for heavy use.
  • You have a developer and want control. n8n can run on your own server, which keeps the data in-house. It is “fair-code” rather than open source in the strict sense: free to self-host for internal business use, with a paid cloud option.

Most small businesses need one tool, not three. Pick the one that fits the systems you already run, and stick with it.

The setup mistakes that cause trouble later

  • Built on one person’s personal account. When they leave, the automations stop or keep running in their name. Use a business account, owned by the company.
  • No error alerts. Automations fail silently: an expired login or a changed form field, and nothing happens. Turn on failure notifications and send them to a shared inbox.
  • Too much access. Connect each app with the least access the flow needs, not an administrator login.
  • Nobody knows what exists. Keep a simple list of every automation: what it does, which accounts it uses, and who owns it.
  • Automating a bad process. Fix the process first. Automating a messy one just makes the mess faster.

Do you need a tool at all?

Often not. Xero, Shopify, Microsoft 365 and most modern systems have automation built in: repeating invoices, bank rules, payment reminders, approval workflows. Use those first. Our guide on how to automate Xero covers what is already in the subscription, and connecting Shopify to Xero covers the most common online-store connection.

Frequently asked questions

Is Power Automate free with Microsoft 365?

Microsoft 365 business licences include Power Automate with standard connectors, such as Outlook, SharePoint, Teams and Excel. Premium connectors and some advanced features need a separate paid Power Automate licence. Microsoft’s licensing FAQ has the current detail.

Is Zapier or Power Automate better?

Neither in general. Power Automate suits businesses built on Microsoft 365. Zapier suits businesses that use many different cloud apps and want the quickest setup.

What is the difference between Zapier and Make?

Both connect cloud apps. Zapier is simpler to start and has more app connections. Make is more visual and handles complex, many-step scenarios well, and is often cheaper at higher volumes because of how it counts usage.

Is n8n free?

n8n can be self-hosted free of charge for internal business use under its own Sustainable Use Licence. Its managed cloud service and some enterprise features are paid. Self-hosting means someone has to run and update the server.

How we help

We find the repetitive work worth automating, choose the tool that fits the systems you already run, and build the automations under a business account, with error alerts and a written list of what runs where. See our business process automation work, or contact us.

Sources

  1. Microsoft Learn: Power Automate licensing FAQ
  2. Make Help Centre: credits as the billing unit

Read next

Know the number for your business.

Tell us what is going on. We will tell you whether a Snapshot, the Full Diagnostic or neither is the right next step.

Contact us