WordPress, Shopify or a static site: which does your business need?
There is no best website platform, only the one that fits how your business uses its site. What each option costs to keep running, who can edit it, and when to leave a working site alone.
- 40% of all websites run on WordPress
- 91% of new WordPress security flaws in 2025 were in plugins
- 5 hours median time from a flaw going public to the first attack
“Should we be on WordPress?” is one of the questions we hear most from business owners, usually just after someone has quoted them for a new website. The honest answer is that there is no best platform. There is the one that fits how your business actually uses its website: how often it changes, who changes it, whether it sells anything, and who will look after it once it is live.
This guide compares the four options most small businesses choose between, in plain terms, and ends with the questions to answer before you rebuild anything.
The short version
- WordPress runs about 40% of all websites. It is the most flexible option and the easiest for staff to edit, but it needs regular upkeep: almost all of its security problems come from plugins.
- Shopify is usually the right answer if selling online is the main job. Hosting and platform security are included; apps add monthly costs.
- Hosted builders such as Squarespace and Wix are the quickest way to get a simple site live yourself, with less flexibility as you grow.
- A static site is built in advance and served as plain files. It is very fast and has almost nothing to patch, but changing it usually needs a developer or an added content editor.
The four options in plain terms
WordPress is software that builds each page when someone visits, from a database, a theme and a set of plugins. You choose and pay for the hosting. Its strength is the plugin library: there is one for almost everything, from booking forms to online shops (WooCommerce).
Shopify is an online shop you rent. You pay a monthly plan plus payment fees, and Shopify runs the hosting, security and checkout. Extra features come from apps, most of them with their own monthly fee.
Hosted builders such as Squarespace and Wix work the same way for general websites: a monthly fee, a drag-and-drop editor, and hosting included. They are easy to start with and harder to move away from later.
Static sites are built once, in advance, and served as finished pages from a network of servers close to each visitor. Tools such as Astro build them. There is no database or plugin running on each visit, which is what makes them fast and hard to attack.
1. The cost you don’t see: upkeep
The price of a website is mostly what it costs to keep running, not what it cost to build.
WordPress is a good example. According to Patchstack’s 2026 security report, 11,334 new security flaws were found across WordPress and its add-ons in 2025, up 42% on 2024. 91% were in plugins and 9% in themes; WordPress itself had only six, all low priority. And 46% had no fix from the developer by the time they were made public. Once a flaw is public, the median time to the first attack was five hours.
None of that means WordPress is unsafe. It means a WordPress site needs someone responsible for it.
What to do:
- Keep the number of plugins small, and delete the ones you don’t use rather than just switching them off.
- Turn on automatic updates for plugins you trust, and check the site after major updates.
- Keep daily backups somewhere other than the website’s own server, and test a restore once.
- Name one person, inside the business or out, who is responsible for updates.
With Shopify, hosted builders and static sites, most of this work is done for you or doesn’t exist. That is a real saving, even if it doesn’t appear on a quote.
2. Speed on a phone
Many of your visitors will be on a phone, often on mobile data. Google treats a page as good when its main content appears within 2.5 seconds, and you can check yours for free with PageSpeed Insights or our website check.
Static sites are usually fast without trying, because the pages already exist before anyone asks for them. WordPress can be just as fast, but it depends on the theme, the number of plugins and the hosting. A slow WordPress site is often fixed by removing plugins and resizing images, not by rebuilding.
3. Who edits it, and how often
This question decides more than any other.
- If your team publishes news, events, menus or new pages every week, WordPress or a hosted builder lets them do it without calling anyone.
- If the site changes a few times a month, a static site works well, with a simple content editor added for the pages that change.
- If products and stock change daily, that is a shop, and Shopify or WooCommerce is built for it.
A good build lets the business edit the words and pictures while keeping the design locked, whatever the platform.
4. Selling online
If selling online is the main job of the site, Shopify is usually the simplest choice: checkout, payments, stock and shipping are built in and kept secure for you. WooCommerce makes sense if you are already on WordPress and want everything in one place, but the upkeep in section 1 then applies to your shop too.
5. Connecting to the rest of the business
A website rarely stands alone. Orders need to reach the accounting system, enquiries need to reach a CRM or an inbox someone watches, and bookings need to reach a calendar. Every platform can do this, through plugins, apps or a small piece of custom work. What matters is that someone sets it up, so nobody is retyping orders into Xero by hand. Our guide to automating invoices and expenses covers the finance side.
Which fits?
| If your website mainly… | Usually the best fit |
|---|---|
| Sells products online | Shopify, or WooCommerce if you’re already on WordPress |
| Gets new pages or posts from staff every week | WordPress, kept updated, or a hosted builder |
| Explains your services and brings in enquiries | A static site, or a hosted builder if you’ll edit it yourself |
| Needs to be live this month, built by you | A hosted builder such as Squarespace or Wix |
What we use, and why
Our own website is a static site, built with Astro. It suits us: we add new guides often, but we write code, so we don’t need a drag-and-drop editor, and we would rather spend our time on the guides than on plugin updates. If your team edits pages every day and nobody writes code, a well-kept WordPress site may suit you better. We don’t resell any platform or hosting, so the recommendation is whatever fits.
When to leave a working site alone
A rebuild makes sense when the platform itself is the obstacle: nobody can update it, it can’t be made fast, or it can’t connect to the systems you run on. It doesn’t make sense when the problem is a few slow images, a broken contact form or out-of-date plugins. Those are fixes, and they cost a fraction of a new site. Our guide to six website checks helps tell the two apart.
Before you choose or rebuild
- Write down how often the site changes, and who changes it.
- List what it must connect to: bookings, payments, the accounting system, a CRM.
- Ask what it will cost to run each year, not just to build: hosting, plugins or apps, updates and support.
- Check whose name the domain is registered in, and who holds the logins.
- Run a free speed check on your current site before deciding it is too slow.
If you’d like a second opinion on your website or the systems behind it, contact us.
Sources
Share this